EbizMBA just posted a list of the Top 25 Most Popular Blogs on the internet. It’s pretty interesting, definitely more accurate than any one of the previous single metric systems. Obviously it’s tech heavy and it doesn’t account for which sites on are a downward slide and which ones are on their way up. Shouldn’t it matter how old those inbound links are? Gawker has been around forever, but it’s clearly no longer the definitive source for celebrity news yet the old, stagnant number of links makes it seem like it is. But let’s put all that aside for a minute and consider this:
What if we’re ignoring the most important part of the equation?
I asked this same question at SXSW to Henry Copeland of Blogads, who put together an excellent presentation on such misleading metric systems. Actually, I posed it to the losers who were bloviating on topics they had no authority to discuss but that’s a different story. What about money? Isn’t that what this is all about? Or are we all setting up websites so we can meet friends? In the end, let’s be honest, isn’t the point of traffic to translate it into dollars?
So then I am not being unreasonable when I assert that these rankings need to provide proof. We need to see the fungibility of their traffic. Can you take Crooks and Liars 150,00+ visitors a month to the bank, or are they providing a public service? Shouldn’t the ratio of visitors to ad revenue count for and against these sites? Let’s say you have (and these are absurd ratios obviously) a relationship with your traffic where 1 visitor translates to $1 in earnings, aren’t you more popular, and better than a site where 1 visitor equals 30 cents? Doesn’t that say something about the quality of your traffic and isn’t that significant? Movies would have larger audiences if they gave the tickets away for free but that wouldn’t mean much. Real businessmen and women measure by results, not feel good numbers. Just like Hollywood ought to measure their box office numbers in the context of how much it cost to make and advertise, websites should rank based on their traffic in terms of how it relates to revenue. To suggest that all sites do this equally or there is some natural law governing visitors and ads is simply not true.
Michael Lewis understood this in Moneyball as far as baseball worked. Team batting average, stolen bases, fielding percentage–these are all worthless metrics. They don’t really mean anything, they just make us feel good. Pure traffic is EXACTLY the same thing. It doesn’t mean anything–wasn’t that the whole point of the long tail? That shit is going to change; the idea that these numbers will stay the same is hopelessly idealistic. Do you really think that in 10 years some site about cool firefox hacks and laptop batteries is going to be the tenth most popular blog on the internet? Billy Beane figured out what was important, what translated into wins. The internet needs to look at the problem the same way or this is all a big circle-jerk fantasy.
My opinion is that money has to be incorporated into the equation, and I would say immediately. But perhaps it should be something else. All I know is that pure traffic and inbound links are meaningless without context. We’re kidding ourselves if we think RSS subscription numbers are in anyway more illumination. For the most part, they run zero-sum with traffic, so what do they really tell us? SEO isn’t going to be able to game revenue. And it might be cliche, but money talks and the rest is bullshit.
The web isn’t any different.
- Gawker Domain & Archive Is Finally Up For Auction This Week. Who Might Win, and Why? July 8, 2018
- What Peter Thiel’s Playbook Shows Us About Taking Down Trump, Alex Jones (or Anyone) April 26, 2018
- In Praise of Conspiracies March 14, 2018
- It’s Time to Get Real About Power in Silicon Valley February 28, 2018
- The Insane Backstory Behind The Lawyer Who Shook Down Donald Trump (and Hulk Hogan) January 15, 2018
- Seriously, You—OK, We—Need To Stop Watching The News This Year January 1, 2018
- The Unstoppable Power of Greeting It All With a Smile December 18, 2017
- I Tried to Expose Russia’s Media Manipulation Playbook in 2012 and Nobody Listened November 27, 2017
- How Lewis Howes Got to 40M Podcast Downloads, the Bestseller List, and Ellen’s Couch October 31, 2017
- The Unfathomable Power of Amor Fati October 13, 2017
- The Media Needs to Look in the Mirror After Harvey Weinstein October 10, 2017
- Exclusive: The Authors of Blue Ocean Strategy Reveal How They Sold 4M Copies September 26, 2017
- Why the Best Thing You Can Do for Your Creative Project Is Create Another One September 12, 2017
- These 25 Businesses Will Surprise You With How Old They Are August 23, 2017
- A Fingertip Feel for the Internet: An Interview With Professional Meme Creator Ka5sh August 8, 2017
- How To Create Art (And Work) That Lasts July 12, 2018
- 3.1 Lessons Learned on the Way to 31 June 16, 2018
- What Can This Five-Century-Old Drawing Teach You? Everything That Matters. May 30, 2018
- 22 Rules for Creating Work That Stands the Test of Time May 14, 2018
- Here’s How You Stop Anger From Making You Do Something Stupid May 7, 2018
- Don’t Fake It ‘Till You Make It. Do This Instead. May 1, 2018
- How Your Daily Routine Can Turn Into Your Biggest Enemy April 24, 2018
- 13 Life-Changing Habits To Try And Do Every Single Day April 15, 2018
- Here’s The Technique That Ambitious People Use To Get What They Want March 29, 2018
- The Most Successful People Are The Ones You’ve Never Heard Of (And Why They Want It That Way) March 20, 2018